Emkay PMS

Our view on their team, the pedigree, the funds & investment philosophy followed.

IME's Review of Emkay PMS

AMC RatingPedigree RatingTeam RatingPhilosophy Rating
Upgrade
Upgrade
Upgrade
Upgrade
AMC Pedigree
Upgrade
Team Pedigree
Upgrade
FM Churn Risk
Upgrade
AMC Maturity
Upgrade
Philosphy Name
Upgrade
Inv Philosophy
Upgrade
Investment Team
Upgrade

AMC View

Emkay PMS has strong broking credentials and follows a process-oriented approach to investment management. Although they have a stronger reputation in mid-cap stocks, we appreciate their clearly articulated fundamental process frameworks used for portfolio building. The firm also suffers from high churn risk in its investment team given the lack of controlling ownership by the investment team.

AMC Pedigree

The Emkay group is a credible 2nd tier institutional broking house with a strong background in equity broking. Their PMS division has been developed based on these research credentials, although their credentials in terms of PMS are not as strong as top-tier providers in the market.

Team Pedigree

Emkay's investment team, led by Sachin Shah, has a strong investment pedigree, particularly in portfolios using the Classical Alpha approach. Recently, the team was further strengthened when Manish Sonthalia joined after spending almost 2 decades at Motilal.

Investment Philosophy

Emkay has a defined investment process based on two approaches: Classical Alpha (bottom-up stock selection with quality checks) and Smart Alpha (equal-weighted bias-removal strategy).

AMC Background

Emkay PMS is the investment management arm of the broader Emkay Group, a long-established Indian financial services platform with over three decades of capital markets presence. The firm benefits from the institutional lineage, governance culture, and research depth of the Emkay ecosystem, which spans institutional equities, wealth management, and capital markets advisory.

The firm is promoted by Krishna Kumar Karwa and Prakash Kacholia, both seasoned capital market professionals with more than 30 years of experience across equity research, derivatives, market infrastructure, and asset management. This promoter backing lends Emkay a distinctly institutional character, combining entrepreneurial ownership with mature market experience and regulatory familiarity. Day-to-day investment management is led by a stable and experienced investment team, including Sachin Shah and Manish Sonthalia, supported by a dedicated research function. The team’s collective experience exceeds multiple decades, with strong continuity in both philosophy and personnel, particularly within flagship strategies that have been managed through multiple market cycles.

Investment Philosophy

Emkay’s investment philosophy is built around the principle that long-term wealth creation is driven by compounding in high-quality businesses, and that avoiding permanent capital loss is at least as important as identifying growth opportunities. The firm explicitly prioritises mistake avoidance - steering clear of weak governance, excessive leverage, euphoric valuations, and businesses at risk of structural irrelevance. Investing is approached as a buy-to-hold exercise, with patience before and after investing, low churn, and a focus on absolute wealth creation rather than benchmark-relative outcomes.

At the core of Emkay’s process is a belief that management quality is the single most important determinant of long-term outcomes. This belief is institutionalised through its proprietary E-Qual framework, a governance and management evaluation model that has been under active implementation for over a decade. The framework seeks to objectively quantify qualitative aspects of businesses, allowing Emkay to systematically rank and filter companies based on governance strength and management behaviour, rather than relying on subjective judgment alone.

E-Qual Framework

The E-Qual framework scores companies across multiple dimensions, with a heavy emphasis on management integrity and capability. Key pillars include promoter holding patterns, changes in ownership, equity dilution history, pledging, related-party transactions, auditor quality, capital allocation behaviour, and the quality of investor communication. Each factor is weighted to create an aggregate governance score, which directly influences investability, valuation assumptions, and position sizing. Companies failing minimum governance thresholds are excluded outright, irrespective of apparent valuation or growth appeal.

Risk management is embedded structurally within this framework through clearly defined red flags, including excessive promoter pledging, repeated debt restructuring, high leverage, large unrelated acquisitions, and poor disclosure practices. Emkay’s philosophy is explicit that governance risks are asymmetric and non-compensable, and therefore not suitable for portfolio-level diversification.

Portfolio Construction

Beyond governance, Emkay evaluates businesses through a consistent lens focused on scalability, inherent profitability, and capital efficiency. Preference is given to companies with sustainable ROCE/ROE profiles, self-funded growth, strong balance sheets, and the ability to generate operating and free cash flows across cycles. Valuation discipline plays a central role, with purchase price treated as the fulcrum of alpha generation - recognising that even superior businesses can deliver poor outcomes if acquired at inappropriate valuations.

Portfolio construction reflects this philosophy through focused portfolios, controlled position sizes, and low turnover. Emkay favours long holding periods, allowing business fundamentals to drive returns rather than frequent rebalancing. The firm is sector-agnostic but not style-agnostic, consistently favouring companies where management quality, business economics, and valuation converge favourably. Over time, this has resulted in portfolios where the bulk of gains accrue from long-term holdings rather than trading activity.

Overall, Emkay’s investment philosophy is best characterised as classical, governance-led equity investing - combining disciplined qualitative frameworks, fundamental business analysis, and valuation sensitivity to compound capital steadily while minimising avoidable errors across market cycles.

Investment team

Manish Sonthalia | 4-star rated FM

CEO | 28 yrs Experience | 2 yrs at current firm

Past Experience: SKP Securities (VP), Motilal Oswal

Manish Sonthalia is the new CEO of Emkay. Manish has spent most of his career at Motilal, having joined Motilal in 2004 from SKP Securities. He was the CIO-Equities at Motilal PMS and along with Ramdeo Agarwal has been instrumental in the growth and performance of the PMS strategies.

Sachin Shah | 3-star rated FM

Fund Manager | 28 yrs Experience | 14 yrs at current firm

Past Experience: JJ Bhabhera PMS (FM), Motilal PMS (VP), India Infoline (Analyst), KBS Capital (Analyst)

Sachin has over 2 decades of investment experience, having worked as a fund manager at JJ Bhabhera PMS & Motilal PMS, prior to which he worked as an analyst at IndiaInfoline & KBS Capital. Sachin joined Emkay PMS in Nov-11.

Recommended Funds

No fund performance data available

Experience the benefits of working with a 'research-first' investments firm

Free 15-Day Trial of IME RMS App

Get complimentary access to the revolutionary IME RMS App (direct access to IME's central team insights across 1000's of MFs, PMSs, AIFs & Global funds - a first in the industry).

Additionally, a dedicated private banker will help build your financial plan, investment mandate & undertake a comprehensive portfolio review for free.

IME Capital Logo

IME Capital is a research-first investments firm. We aim to disrupt the wealth management industry, by shrinking the gap in investment insights between central research teams & RMs/Clients.

Disclaimer MF/PMS/AIF/Direct Equities are all subject to market risks. Please read the scheme information and other related documents carefully prior to investing. Past performance is not indicative of future returns. Please consider your specific investment requirements before choosing a fund or designing a portfolio that suits your needs. Market & other data on this site has been sourced from what are considered to be reliable sources. All views shared (product ratings, views on individual securities etc.) are the proprietary property of IME Capital and cannot be used in any form without explicit written consent. IME Capital Pvt. Ltd. makes no warranties or representations, express or implied, on products offered through the platform (and that of our partners) or on the correctness of data & views shared. It accepts no liability for any damages or losses, however caused, in connection with the use of, or on the reliance of its product or related services. Detailed Disclaimer | © 2021 All rights reserved | ARN No: ARN-182445